Skip to content

DIAL response: reframe corpus to development-of-the-mediator criterion, ingest Drive sources, build literature card deck - #764

Merged
rogerSuperBuilderAlpha merged 1 commit into
contribfrom
submission/algorithmacy-google-docs-pass
Sep 22, 2026
Merged

rogerSuperBuilderAlpha merged 1 commit into
contribfrom
submission/algorithmacy-google-docs-pass

Conversation

@rogerSuperBuilderAlpha

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Summary

  • Re-anchor the corpus on a development-of-the-mediator criterion instead of holding Belousov et al.'s 25-novel end-product corpus fixed. Primary corpus is now the 6 purpose-built works (Table 2); 23 of their 25 are drawn on opportunistically, with A16 and A19 tested and excluded (reported, not hidden). Abstract, highlights, intro, §3.1/3.2/3.3, §5 intro, limitations, conclusion, data availability, and Appendix A updated to match; corpus_coding.md and SOURCE.md updated in parallel.
  • Four Google Docs previously inaccessible mid-session pulled and checked against draft.md; genuinely new material (not already absorbed via corpus/essay.md) ingested as provenance under sources/.
  • Ten literature research runs surveyed empirical/theoretical support for claims across §2-§5, producing 194 deduplicated bibliography cards under literature/cards/, an index (REFERENCES.md), and a tiered acquisition list (NEEDS_FULL_TEXT.md).

Known follow-ups (not yet applied in this PR)

  • §4.4 cites the wrong DSA article for the audit-obligation claim (should be Art. 37, not 40); the "platforms withhold" framing overstates what's true.
  • §4.8's "one version behind" claim is cited to a source (Klug et al. 2023) that doesn't support it.
  • §5.2's Shumailov model-collapse citation uses a mismatched mechanism (synthetic-data loop vs. the paper's user-feedback loop).
  • §4.7's "fleet training data" claim (M4) is unsupported as stated and needs hedging.
  • A provenance question is open: an arXiv preprint (Perry & Ammari 2026) closely matches draft.md's own §4.1 AV sentence and needs a human check before anything is cited or kept.
  • The Discussion-theme positional gap against Belousov et al.'s Theme 3/5 (flagged earlier on this branch) is still open.

Test plan

  • Read-through of the reframed corpus section (§3.1) for coherence
  • Spot-check a handful of literature cards against their source memos
  • Resolve the Perry & Ammari provenance question before further citation work

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

…, build literature card deck

Corpus: re-anchor on a development-of-the-mediator criterion instead of
holding Belousov et al.'s 25-novel end-product corpus fixed. Primary corpus
is now the 6 purpose-built works (Table 2); 23 of their 25 are drawn on
opportunistically (A16, A19 tested and excluded, reported not hidden).
Updates abstract, highlights, intro, §3.1/3.2/3.3, §5 intro, limitations,
conclusion, data availability, and Appendix A to match; corpus_coding.md
and SOURCE.md updated in parallel.

Sources: four Google Docs previously inaccessible mid-session are pulled
and checked against draft.md, with genuinely new material (not already
absorbed via corpus/essay.md) ingested as provenance under sources/.

Literature: ten research runs (Opus) surveyed the empirical/theoretical
support for claims across §2-§5, producing 194 deduplicated bibliography
cards under literature/cards/, an index (REFERENCES.md), and a tiered
acquisition list (NEEDS_FULL_TEXT.md). Several runs surfaced real fixes
still to be applied to draft.md, not yet made in this commit: the DSA
citation in §4.4 names the wrong article, the algospeak "one version
behind" claim in §4.8 is cited to a source that doesn't support it, the
Shumailov model-collapse citation in §5.2 uses a mismatched mechanism,
and the M4 "fleet training data" claim in §4.7 is unsupported as stated.
A provenance question also remains open: an arXiv preprint's wording
closely matches draft.md's own §4.1 AV sentence and needs a human check.
The Discussion-theme positional gap against Belousov et al.'s Theme 3/5
(flagged earlier this branch) is also still open.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@rogerSuperBuilderAlpha
rogerSuperBuilderAlpha merged commit db8fcb0 into contrib Sep 22, 2026
2 checks passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant